Sunday, April 08, 2007

"Sick" a new book

Yes, that's the title of a new book written by Jonathan Cohn, a senior editor at The New Republic. The book is reviewed in the New York Times by Sally Satel, who is a physician and a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute. An excerpt from this excellent review:

“Sick” does not offer a prescription for our ailing health care system, but it does include a closing chapter on what to do. Here the argument turns tendentious. Critics of universal coverage, Cohn writes, often traffic in alarmist tales “about rationing and waiting lines, followed by a horror story from Britain or Canada.” Those complaints are “wildly exaggerated” and also unfair, he says, because the problem is not the result of universal health care but “of universal health care on the cheap.” But Cohn is himself being unfair when he sweepingly denounces “the principles of modern conservatism” for being “conspicuously short on ... comfort or hope.” In truth, there is nothing inherently pessimistic in choice, self-reliance or limited bureaucracy — the values that underlie a market-based proposal like the one introduced by Senator Ron Wyden, an Oregon Democrat. In this plan, employers would no longer provide insurance and would instead convert those costs into a bigger paycheck, enabling workers to buy private insurance from providers who would then be forced to compete for business by offering better plans. (Wyden’s proposal also offers subsidies for the unemployed.)
Click here to read the entire review (registration required).

No comments: